Skip to content
Quickly Cooked
Back to recipes
Italian Vegetarian Advanced

Pumpkin & Amaretti Tortelli

A crushed amaretti cookie in the filling is the trick nobody expects — it turns roast pumpkin faintly bitter and much more interesting.

4.7 (412 reviews) · 105 min total · Serves 4
Jump to recipe Plan this recipe Substitutions
Hand-folded tortelli dusted with flour on a wooden board

Recipe facts

Servings

4

4 servings

Scale quantities from 1 to 24 servings

Prep

60 min

Cook

45 min

Total

105 min

Difficulty
Advanced
Cuisine
Italian
Dietary
Vegetarian
Category
Dinner

Overview

About this recipe

Pumpkin & Amaretti Tortelli is a advanced dinner recipe from our Italian files, built from 9 ingredients and 7 steps and timed at 105 minutes from board to table. A crushed amaretti cookie in the filling is the trick nobody expects — it turns roast pumpkin faintly bitter and much more interesting.

As written it yields 4 servings, and the ingredient list rescales with the servings control below so the shopping quantities always match what you are actually cooking. It is logged as vegetarian in our catalog, with 60 minutes of hands-on prep and 45 minutes of cooking — useful to know if you are slotting it into a busy evening.

Worth cooking

Why you'll love it

  • Mostly unattended

    45 minutes of cooking that needs little from you after the first 60.

  • Advanced to follow

    7 numbered steps and 9 ingredients, nothing hidden.

  • Vegetarian as written

    And the substitutions section covers the common swaps if you need to shift it further.

  • Scales cleanly

    Written for 4, adjustable from 1 to 24 servings with quantities recalculated for you.

  • Tested and re-tested

    Rated 4.7 across 412 cooks in our recipe box.

  • Italian flavours

    Filed under dinner — see the variations below for other directions.

From the recipe box

Pumpkin & Amaretti Tortelli

Yield
4 servings
Prep
60 min
Cook
45 min
Total
105 min

Shopping list

Ingredients

0 of 9 gathered · scaled for 4 servings

Nutrition total for 4 servings

Calories
2392
Protein
96 g
Carbohydrates
272 g
Fat
96 g
Fibre
20 g

Catalog values are per serving estimates, multiplied here for the selected servings.

Step by step

Method

  1. Knead the flour, eggs and yolk into a smooth, firm dough, about 10 minutes, then wrap and rest for 30 minutes.

  2. Roast the pumpkin cut side down at 400°F (200°C) for 45 minutes, until collapsing, then scoop out and drain the flesh well.

  3. Mash the pumpkin with the crushed amaretti, parmesan, nutmeg and salt; it should hold a soft peak.

  4. Roll the pasta into thin sheets, cut 2 1/2-inch squares, and place a teaspoon of filling on each.

  5. Fold into triangles, pressing out all the air, then bring the two points together and pinch to seal.

  6. Boil in salted water for 3 to 4 minutes, until the seams are tender.

  7. Foam the butter with the sage in a wide pan, add the drained tortelli with a splash of pasta water, and toss to coat before serving with parmesan.

Cook's note

Drain the roast pumpkin in a sieve for twenty minutes. Wet filling is the only reason home-made tortelli burst in the pot.

Swaps that work

Ingredient substitutions

5 swaps matched to this ingredient list, with quantities shown for 4 servings. The ratios stay the same at any scale.

  • Dairy 1:1 by weight (oil: use 3/4 of the butter weight)

    Instead of 4 tbsp unsalted butter

    Vegan block butter, or olive oil for savoury dishes

    Dairy-free and still rich. Oil gives a softer, denser crumb in baking, so keep butter where you need creaming or browning.

  • Dairy 1:1 grated; yeast at half the volume

    Instead of 1/2 cup (45 g) grated parmesan, plus more to serve

    Aged vegetarian hard cheese, or nutritional yeast plus a pinch of salt

    Keeps the savoury depth. Nutritional yeast will not melt, so stir it in off the heat.

  • Eggs 1 flax egg per egg, rested 10 minutes

    Instead of 3 large eggs, plus 1 yolk

    Flax egg — 1 tbsp ground flaxseed whisked with 3 tbsp water

    Binds well in loaves, pancakes and pastry washes. Avoid it where whipped whites provide the lift.

  • Flour & grains 1:1 by weight

    Instead of 300 g '00' flour

    Measure-for-measure gluten-free blend containing xanthan gum

    Gluten-free. Hydration is slower, so rest the batter or dough 20 minutes longer and expect a slightly more tender crumb.

  • Herbs Dried at one third the volume

    Instead of 12 sage leaves

    Other woody herbs, or 1 tsp dried per tablespoon fresh

    Dried woody herbs hold up in long cooking but will not crisp, so add them earlier for flavour.

Options

Make it your own

  • Add some heat

    A pinch of chilli flakes bloomed in the cooking fat, or a spoonful of chilli crisp at the table, lifts the dish without rewriting it.

  • Make it more substantial

    Fold in a cooked grain or a tin of drained beans; add a little extra salt and acid, since the starch will absorb both.

  • Dairy-free version

    The dairy swaps below are all 1:1 or close to it. Expect a slightly leaner texture rather than a different dish.

  • Gluten-free version

    A measure-for-measure blend or gluten-free pasta works; watch the timing, which usually runs a few minutes shorter.

  • Change the herb

    Soft herbs swap by volume. Keep the woody ones in the cooking and the tender ones for finishing.

At the table

Serving suggestions

  • Rest before serving so the juices settle rather than run onto the plate.
  • Something starchy to catch the sauce: bread, mash, plain rice or buttered noodles.
  • A bitter or acidic side — chicory, dressed greens, quick pickles — to cut the richness.
  • Spoon every scrap of pan juice over the plates; that is where the seasoning lives.

Get it right

Success tips

  1. Read the method through once before you start and set out the ingredients — most mistakes happen mid-step.
  2. Weigh or measure to the list at your chosen serving size; the quantities above are already scaled for 4 as written.
  3. Heat the oven fully before anything goes in, and give food space on the pan — crowded trays steam instead of browning.
  4. Taste and adjust salt and acid at the end. A squeeze of lemon or a splash of vinegar fixes more dishes than extra salt does.
  5. Cook's note: Drain the roast pumpkin in a sieve for twenty minutes. Wet filling is the only reason home-made tortelli burst in the pot.

Keeping it

Storage & make-ahead

Fridge

Cool to room temperature within two hours, then refrigerate in an airtight container for 3 to 4 days. Keep any sauce or pan juices with the food — it reheats far better wet than dry.

Freezer

Freezes well for up to 3 months in flat, airtight portions with plenty of liquid. Thaw overnight in the fridge; anything crisp or fresh is better added again at serving.

Reheating

Warm gently, covered, over low heat or in a 325°F (165°C) oven until hot through, loosening with a spoonful of stock or water. Re-season and add fresh herbs or acid at the end.

Make ahead

With 60 minutes of prep, most of the chopping, mixing and measuring can be done a day early and refrigerated. Leave the final 45 minutes of cooking, and any finishing herbs, acid or dairy, for the day you serve.

Kit

Equipment checklist

  • Oven, fully preheated
  • Rolling pin or pasta roller
  • Sieve or colander
  • Microplane or fine grater
  • Digital scale, mixing bowls, sharp knife and board
  • Large mixing bowl and a smaller one for dressings or seasonings
  • Wooden spoon or silicone spatula for stirring and scraping
  • Measuring cups and spoons, plus a ladle for serving

Questions

Frequently asked

Can I change the number of servings?

Yes. The recipe is written for 4 servings and the control in the recipe card rescales every ingredient quantity and the nutrition estimate from 1 to 24 servings. Cooking times change far less than quantities do, so use the visual and temperature cues in the method rather than the clock.

How far ahead can I make it?

Most of the 60 minutes of prep can be done a day ahead and refrigerated. Leave the 45 minutes of cooking and any fresh finishing — herbs, acid, dairy, crisp toppings — for serving day. The storage section above has the specifics.

What if I am missing an ingredient?

Check the substitutions section: each swap lists a workable ratio and what it changes about flavour, texture or timing. Salt, acid and fat are the elements worth keeping honest; almost everything else has a sensible stand-in.

Is this recipe really vegetarian?

As written, yes — it is filed as vegetarian in our catalog. If you swap ingredients, check labels on stock, cheese and condiments, which are the usual places animal products hide.

My timing came out differently — what happened?

Pan size, how full the pan is, and how cold the ingredients were all shift timing by several minutes. Trust the described look and feel at each step, and give the food room so it browns instead of steaming.